Sunday, September 5, 2010

Unions driving the nation without brakes

South Africa is in full swing of an extended strike season – that special time of year when different public and private sector employees take to the streets in mass demonstration as is their constitutional right.

Every year the same questions are asked of the union leaders who organise these rhythmically engaging events (a lot of dancing and singing and destruction of property takes place):
  • How can an increase be seen as a right whether earned or not
  • When did a subsidy turn into full payment of the expense being subsidised
  • Where in the world do employees earn the same as management (it doesn't even happen in the communist states that are left)
  • The policy for striking workers is 'no work no pay', so why do you not share this same fate as the people you encourage to forgo their wages

In their defence union leaders have degrees in glossing over questions with political and 'for the good of the people' pre-written speeches, so we will never really get answers.

It stands to reason that employers offer low increases to cover the inevitable barrage of union negotiations. We have reached a cross-roads and it is time for a revamp of what unions represent and how they go about their business. Because that is essentially what a union is; a business! They are organisations that solicit members who pay a monthly fee for possible future services.

Has strike action become an expectation in return for the monthly membership fee?

Apart from negotiating your yearly increase, unions have added a range of services to make their organisation more attractive to future and current members. These services range from legal advise to funeral cover and educational trusts. Will they eventually offer you cheaper cinema and airline tickets as part of member benefits?

There was a time when unions were needed, but surely we have outgrown them. In my view unions are in the insurance industry (security against the possibility of future wage or employment dispute) and have no cause getting involved in politics and promoting themselves as part of civil society.

Is the case that unions know this and are doing everything possible to keep themselves in the picture?

Next week: space exploration

No comments:

Post a Comment